Breakthrough: Self-Exclusion
By: Kolleen Lucariello

I had just finished telling myself a story regarding a particular situation with a family member. I had written quite the script, too. It had the elements of betrayal, misunderstanding, and drama. The only thing lacking was any actual fact. It was all just a made-up story in my head as I read into years of unmet expectations within the dynamics of our family.
As I began to consider the next chapter, I had an uncomfortable thought run through my mind: “Stop thinking for everybody else.” Ouch. How's that for a bit of conviction?
Apparently, I had not only written the script, but I had assigned motives, interpreted intentions, and decided what everyone else must be thinking. I had become the writer, director, and producer of a story in which I had very little factual information. And the longer I entertained it, the more believable it became.
Have you ever done that? Someone says something, doesn't say something, responds a certain way, or doesn't respond at all, and suddenly your mind starts filling in the blanks? Before you know it, you've developed an entire explanation for their behavior. You might even find yourself responding to them based on something they never actually said or intended.
We can be remarkably convincing storytellers when our stories are fueled by hurt.
And when those hurts are connected to years of unmet expectations, the stories can become even more convincing. A present situation can stir up the emotions of past pain or disappointments, and suddenly we're not just reacting to what happened today. We're reacting to everything we believe it means.
The problem is that what we assume is not necessarily what is true.
Self-exclusion is not always someone telling us we don't belong. Sometimes, it's a conclusion we reach on our own. We assume we're unwanted, so we withdraw. We assume someone meant to hurt us, so we become defensive. We assume we know what another person thinks, so we stop asking questions. We anticipate rejection and begin protecting ourselves from something that may not even happen. Without realizing it, we can exclude ourselves from the possibility of understanding, connection, and peace before anyone has actually closed the door. This can lead us into self-isolation.
And here's what I had to recognize about myself: I was allowing my assumptions to influence my feelings about a situation without giving the other person an opportunity to speak for themselves. I was thinking for them instead of taking responsibility for my own thoughts. That distinction matters.
We cannot control what someone else thinks, feels, says, or does. We cannot rewrite the past or force people to meet our expectations. But we can take responsibility for the stories we tell ourselves about those things. Second Corinthians 10:5 reminds us to take our thoughts captive and make them obedient to Christ. That means we don't have to accept every thought that enters our minds as truth. We can stop, examine it, and ask God to help us discern what is true.
Is this a fact, or is it an assumption?
Am I responding to what actually happened, or to what old wounds tell me?
Have I given this person the opportunity to explain, or have I already decided what they meant?
These questions don't dismiss our hurt or suggest that every painful situation is simply a misunderstanding. Sometimes people do disappoint us. Sometimes relationships are unhealthy. Sometimes we need to establish boundaries. Self-awareness doesn't require us to ignore reality; it invites us to distinguish reality from the meaning we've assigned to it.
That little thought — “Stop thinking for everybody else” — reminded me that I have enough responsibility managing my own thoughts without trying to manage everyone else's.
I don't know every person's motives. I don't know what they are carrying, what they are processing, or why they respond the way they do. Unless they tell me, I cannot know for certain what is happening inside their minds. And neither can you.
We can ask questions instead of making accusations. We can communicate instead of conclude. We can extend grace without pretending hurt doesn't exist. We can choose to address what we know rather than react to what we imagine. Most importantly, we can invite God to examine our own hearts before we decide we understand someone else's.
Psalm 139:23–24 offers a beautiful prayer: “Search me, O God, and know my heart; test me and know my anxious thoughts” (NLT). Notice where the prayer begins. Not with Search them, God. Not with Show me what they're thinking. It begins with Search me. That's where breakthrough begins, too.
I don't know that I'll ever completely stop my mind from trying to fill in the blanks. But I can learn to recognize when it's happening. I can pause before turning an assumption into a conclusion. I can acknowledge my feelings without allowing them to become evidence for a story I cannot prove. And I can remind myself that I don't have to finish writing the story today.
I can leave room for a conversation.
I can leave room for a different perspective.
I can leave room for God to work in places I cannot see or control.
Perhaps the breakthrough isn't in finally figuring out what everyone else is thinking. Perhaps it's in realizing that I don't need to. I don't have to think for everybody else. I need to let God work in me.
Because sometimes, the person keeping me from the peace and connection I desire isn't necessarily the person I think has excluded me. Sometimes, it's the story I've allowed old wounds to tell me about them. And I don't want to keep excluding myself from what God may be inviting me into simply because I've mistaken an assumption for the truth.
Breakthrough from self-exclusion begins when we stop writing other people's stories and allow God to transform the way we respond. It's learning to recognize when old wounds are influencing our present perceptions, challenge the assumptions we've accepted as truth, and choose our responses according to the truth of God's Word rather than the stories our wounds have written.
Let's learn to overcome the habit of isolating ourselves based on what we fear is true; it's time to discover the freedom that comes when we allow God to lead us beyond our assumptions and into the peace, connection, and relationships He may be inviting us to experience.
If you are excluding yourself from community, we want you to know there's a seat for you within Activ8Her. God created us for relationship. Find a chapter here.




Comments